| Grade / Year | Coach | Date | Round | Opponent (District) | Venue | Score | Dunbar goalscorers | Notable occurrences |
| First Grade Men | ||||||||
| 2010 (Waratah Cup) | Charlie De Sousa | Apr 7, 2010 | Prelim | Barden Ridgebacks (Sutherland) | The Ridge Sportsfields, Barden Ridge | 2-1 | Hemmingway, Smith | |
| Apr 21, 2010 | Round 1 | Collaroy Cromer (Manly Warringah) | St. Mathews Farm Reserve, Cromer | 2-3 | Waller, Porter | Bannie gave away a penalty and got sent off. | ||
| 2011 (Waratah Cup) | Charlie De Sousa | Mar 30, 2011 | Prelim | Rydalmere FC (Granville) | Jensen Park, Sefton | 6-2 | Trotter(2), Hemmingway(2), Glasheen, Clayton | |
| Apr 13, 2011 | Round 1 | Pacific Hills (Gladesville Hornsby) | Christie Park, Marsfield | 1-2 aet | Smith | James Myer sent off for swearing at the ref | ||
| 2012 (Waratah Cup) | Charlie De Sousa | Mar 27 2012 | Prelim | Belmore Hercules (Canterbury) | Hensley Athletic Field, Eastgardens | 2-1 aet | Glasheen(2) | |
| Apr 4, 2012 | Round 1 | Tarrawanna (Illawarra Premier League) | Memorial Park, Corrimal | 0-4 | James Myer gets injured and has to go off. Charlie De Sousa goes in goal | |||
| 2013 (Waratah Cup) | Will Cullen | Mar 27 2013 | Round 1 | Springwood United (Nepean) | Summerhayes Park, Winmalee | 11-1 | Millington-Buck(4), Deasy(2), Glasheen(2), O'Shaughnessy, Smith, Keogh | |
| Apr 10, 2013 | Round 2 | Padstow United (Bankstown) | Playford Park, Padstow | 3-0 | Delaney, Deasy, Van Rooyen | |||
| Apr 24, 2013 | Round 3 | Balmain Tigers (State League 1) | 5sports, Caringbah | 3-1 | Delaney, Glasheen, Millington-Buck | One of the best performances in the history of the club | ||
| May 7, 2013 | Round 4 | Northern Tigers (NPL NSW 2) | Cook Park, Asquith | 1-2 | Millington-Buck | Northern Tigers played the ball into the corner for the last couple of minutes of the game | ||
| 2014 (Waratah Cup) | Will Cullen | Mar 15, 2014 | Round 1 | Uni NSW (State League 2) | David Phillips, Daceyville | 1-0 | Deasy | Abandoned after 30 minutes due to torrential rain and waterlogged field |
| Mar 20, 2014 | Round 1 | Uni NSW (State League 2) | David Phillips, Daceyville | 3-0 | Deasy, Crawley, XXX | |||
| Mar 22, 2014 | Round 2 | Parramatta City (Granville) | Mission Field, Centennial Park | 5-1 | Flood(3), Delaney, Crawley | |||
| Apr 9. 2014 | Round 3 | Hakoah Sydney City East (State League 1) | 5sports, Caringbah | 0-2 | ||||
| 2015 (FFA Cup) | Will Cullen | Mar 14, 2015 | Round 3 | Camden Tigers (State League 2) | Ron Dine Stadium, Camden | 1-3 | Miller, Doddy(pen), Niyonsaba | |
| Mar 31, 2015 | Round 4 | Bankstown City (NPL NSW 2) | 5sports, Caringbah | 2-5 | Doddy, Deasy | Michael Beauchamp, 22 times Socceroo played for Bankstown | ||
| 2016 (FFA Cup) | Will Cullen | Mar 16, 2016 | Round 3 | Chatswood Rangers (Northern Suburbs) | Charles Bean Sportsfield, Lindfield | 0-5 | Nicolosi(2), Green, Sealy, Ezekiel | |
| SUMMARY Year 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 |
Round Round 1 Round 1 Round 1 Round 4 Round 3 Round 4 Round 4 |
No. of games 2 games 2 games 2 games 4 games 3 games 2 games 2 games |